Ok..so I finally decided to start dating again

And I thought I had it all figured out but this one got me guessing what's gonna happen next.
He's extremely handsome. 6"1', green eyes... and confident. I normally don't get intimidated by guys..but he kind made my self-confident a bit shaky. I never showed that I was nervous though- which ended up being a good thing cuz he did tell me that found my "confident" to be an attractive quality.
so far there's been 2 dates. He's really sweet and nice. And if I didnt' know better, I'd think he's a great guy. But then a friend of mines ran across his 'myspace' page and directed me to it. So here's the shocker...he has 2 pages devoted to himself!!! And pretty much come across as a Vain, Arrogant, Conceited person. A Man-whore too.
So now I'm just trying to figure which one is the real person and which one is the "front". BTW...he tried to kiss me on the 1st date, I backed off- and told him I don't kiss on the 1st date; his reply was "I don't know any girl that still moves this slow"... I just said "there's a first time for everthing." But we set a second date.
Second date was nice... he busted my lips playing air hockey! the puck flew up and hit me in the face.. on my mouth and pretty much swell up my lips! Embarassing but funny.

He tried to kiss me again and again I pulled back.. 2 reason, 1- my lips hurted like hell and 2- there were kids around everywhere and I'm not a fan of PDA.
So how many more dates will it take before I can tell what his true intentions are.... and am I right to trust my instinct that he's just playing with me or am I so paranoid about getting hurt that I'm pushing away someone that could possible be genuienly interested ?