Of those three I would pick the first one no question.
As far as five-spokers go, I have always loved these:
It also comes in athracite (dark grey) and in chrome.
This website has those wheels and a pretty good variety of other nice wheels
americanracing.com (if you go there, keep in mind while browsing that a lot of the wheels you see depicted in the pictures come in other colors/finishes).
I was just browsing and came across another cool looking five-spoker (well, kinda ten but same concept) and I thought they looked nice; they only come in all chrome though (there are similar ones available that come in other colors).
Come to think of it, those look a lot like the wheels you have now--I sort of just assumed you had the 6MT for some reason.